Issue 652: Three Score and Ten: duplicated?

Object

Fun'raising Scottish Country Dances (Publication)

Submitter

Eric Ferguson (EricFerguson)

Assigned to

Eric Ferguson

Priority

Normal

Disposition

Fixed

Description

'StateBlock' object has no attribute 'is_code_block'

There are three strathspeys 4C/4L of this name on SCDDB:

1.  http://my.strathspey.org/dd/dance/14681/ (by Shirley Sim, published in West Lothian Book in 2006.  Nothing needs to be done on this one.

2.  http://my.strathspey.org/dd/dance/15128, by "Sarah Harriman & Torf", and published in "Houston & District 30th Anniversary Collection", page 14.  I have the PDF of this dance, and the page numbering and deviser agree with that PDF.  There is a Minicrib and Eric's Crib.  This dance was entered by me [Eric Ferguson] on Sept. 18, 2013,

3.  http://my.strathspey.org/dd/dance/15466/, by "Sarah Harriman", and published as dance 8 in "Fun'raising Scottish Country Dances", a booklet published by the "West Suffolk branch of the Alzheimer's Society" in 2007.  This entry shows no cribs but one diagram, which exactly corresponds to dance 2 above.  This dance was entered by Keith Rose on 9th June 2014

There is evident confusion.  Obviously the diagram now with dance 3 belongs to dance 2.  We have two different devisers: "Sarah Harriman" and "Sarah Harriman & Torf"; both also have written other dances.  And if dances 2 and 3 are duplicates, why was one published in the UK and the other in the US? 

Could someone who has access to both publications please correct the entries?

Previous Actions

New issue submitted

_Assigned_ changed to »EricFerguson« (previously »None«)  

Both descriptions show the same dance.  One will be deleted.  Fixed.  Eric

Dance 115466 has now been deleted.  Fixed.  Eric